Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism

Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism By George Steiner, Tolstoy or Dostoevsky An Essay in the Old Criticism George Steiner s Tolstoy or Dostoevsky has become a classic among scholars of Russian literature An essay in poetic and philosophic criticism that bears mainly on the Russian masters Tolstoy or Dosto
  • Title: Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism
  • Author: George Steiner
  • ISBN: 9780300069174
  • Page: 494
  • Format: Paperback
  • Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism By George Steiner, George Steiner s Tolstoy or Dostoevsky has become a classic among scholars of Russian literature An essay in poetic and philosophic criticism that bears mainly on the Russian masters, Tolstoy or Dostoevsky deals also with larger themes the epic tradition extending from Homer to Tolstoy the continuity of a tragic world view from Oedipus Rex to King Lear and The BrotherGeorge Steiner s Tolstoy or Dostoevsky has become a classic among scholars of Russian literature An essay in poetic and philosophic criticism that bears mainly on the Russian masters, Tolstoy or Dostoevsky deals also with larger themes the epic tradition extending from Homer to Tolstoy the continuity of a tragic world view from Oedipus Rex to King Lear and The Brothers Karamazov the contrasts between the epic and dramatic modes, between irreconcilably opposed views of God and of history A must for the teacher, student, and intellectually serious reader Kirkus Reviews This is a book that provides new and stimulating insight into the literary masterpieces and thought of the great Russian novelists Moreover, in this work Steiner shows a great depth and breadth of literary knowledge and criticism that is not limited alone to the Russian writers under discussion but to writers of all genres and all literary periods Journal of Religion His is a work of personal criticism, often ingenious, always deeply felt The New York Times Brilliant, provocative, full of insights, this classic study still stands alone and unchallenged in modern criticism as a lucid and erudite study of the contrasting genius of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky Steiner s book is a must for the student, scholar, or general reader who wishes to approach the Russian giants in their full literary and philosophical ambience Robert L Jackson
    Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism By George Steiner,
    • [ô Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism || Ý PDF Read by ✓ George Steiner]
      494 George Steiner
    • thumbnail Title: [ô Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism || Ý PDF Read by ✓ George Steiner]
      Posted by:George Steiner
      Published :2019-011-22T02:44:20+00:00

    About "George Steiner"

    1. George Steiner

      See also George A Steiner, author on Management and Planning.Dr Francis George Steiner is an essayist, novelist, philosopher, literary critic, and educator He has written for The New Yorker for over thirty years, contributing over two hundred reviews Among his many awards, he received The Truman Capote Lifetime Achievement Award from Stanford University 1998 He lives in Cambridge, England, with his wife, historian Zara Shakow Steiner.In 1950 he earned an M.A from Harvard University, where he won the Bell Prize in American Literature, and received his Ph.D from Oxford University Balliol College on a Rhodes Scholarship in 1955 He was then a scholar at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey, for two years He became a founding fellow of Churchill College at the University of Cambridge in 1961, and has been an Extraordinary Fellow there since 1969 Additionally, Steiner accepted the post of Professor of English and Comparative Literature at the University of Geneva in 1974, which he held for 20 years, teaching in four languages He become Professor Emeritus at Geneva University on his retirement in 1994, and an Honorary Fellow at Balliol College at Oxford University in 1995 He has since held the positions of the first Lord Weidenfeld Professor of Comparative Literature and Fellow of St Anne s College at Oxford University from 1994 to 1995, and Norton Professor of Poetry at Harvard University from 2001 to 2002.

    944 thoughts on “Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism”

    1. , Steiner Tolstoy, , , Steiner , Tolstoy Dostoyevsky Shakespeare , , , 19 , , , , Tolstoy Dostoyevksy , Steiner, .


    2. Maybe the best book of literary criticism I ve ever read Steiner s thesis is that these the world s two greatest novelists have rival conceptions of not only the techniques of fiction, but also salvation, society, sin, God, and redemption Tolstoy is in the epic tradition that descends from Homer Dostoevsky, on the other hand, belongs within the bounds of the tragic writers descending from Oedipus Rex My friend Julie and I used to play Tolstoy or Dostoevsky It consisted of us talking about common [...]



    3. A wonderful book As weird and nerdy as it may sound, I enjoyed this book as a portable conversation I carried it in my pocket on the T for me, like a lot of readers, there s just no excuse for empty time and read it intermittently over the course of a couple months It got so I d look forward to a little tete a tete with Professor Steiner amid the din of the trolley cars, heading to my girlfriend s place after a long day of work.Steiner s prose is genteel, measured, with odd Englishy flourishes H [...]


    4. Having a girlfriend devoted to Russian literature I endeavored to read everything by Dostoevsky and Tolstoy She preferred the former, so I almost finished him I preferred Tolstoy and only read a portion of his work Such is love.I approached Steiner with the naive expectation that he would provide me with arguments pro and con our respective preferences, maybe helping me understand and appreciate both my girlfriend and Dostoevsky better He didn t, though I cannot fault his erudition or writing st [...]


    5. NON SOLO DOSTOEVSKIJ vs TOLSTOJMagari esagero, ma questo saggio individua nei due giganti russi i prototipi, o forse meglio le massime espressioni, dei due possibili modi di fare letteratura, vale a dire dei due possibili modi di porsi dell essere umano di fronte al mondo l uomo nella storia del mondo , oppure solo di fronte allo stupore del mondo L esperienza dell uomo un epica o una tragedia Tutto nasce da qui, e in effetti molto difficile che uno si possa sentire in sintonia con entrambi gli [...]



    6. Classic essay comparing the two giants of C19th Russian realism For Steiner, Tolstoy and Dostoevsky are the two greatest novelists of all time, and the spate of Russian C19th realist doorstoppers the vintage of Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Turgeniev, Gogol, Gorky and Goncharov constitues one of the three major pinnacles of western culture alongside Periclean Athens and Elizabethan and Jacobean England One doesn t have to subscribe to this view to admire Steiner s brilliantly lucid, wide ranging analysis [...]


    7. The section on The Idiot my favorite Dostoevsky novel has so many new and thoughtful insights I had to get out the old index cards and make notes I really enjoyed this book He compares Tolstoy s War and Peace to the Iliad of Homer I m surprised and delighted by this analogy the I ponder it, the clear it becomes He also slices out Russian Literature as an anomaly, because it does not fit objective nor subjective criticism Also, the effect of Flaubert is discussed on each author.


    8. This is a superb book It abounds in literary historical insight it goes to the heart of these authors achievements The title is a bit misleading in that it s not really about deciding whether Tolstoy or Dostoevsky is better but about contrasting their literary modes the point of the book, in fact, is that these two figures represent poles of thought and value between which western culture has been torn since its beginnings Steiner s thesis is that, despite the many dislocations of modernity, wes [...]


    9. I ve read this book 4 times since I bought back in the 90s, it provides what I think is an excellent overview of two of the greatest writers of the 19th Century as well as Russia, he clearly shows how different they were in their philosophical artistic theological outlook The book read so well one tends to forget it is a literary critique, I highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in a wonderful study of two great minds and writers.


    10. O melhor livro de cr tica liter ria que teve nas minhas m os, sem d vida Steiner se mergulha na basta produ o liter ria dos dois maiores romancistas russos, Leon Tolstoi e Fiodr Dostoi vski, analisando suas formas de narrar desde um ponto de vista filos fico e muito profundo Um livro de leitura obrigada, que abre olhos e abre mentes e te cativa mais e mais a medida que avan am as p ginas.


    11. Maravilloso Incre ble Creo que no he disfrutado nunca tanto de un ensayo, as que estoy preparad sima para seguir leyendo a Steiner TeamTolstoy, por cierto.


    12. I thoroughly enjoyed Steiner s illuminating comparisons he explains, for example, how Tolstoy is like Homer, how Dostoevsky is like Shakespeare and Melville, and how Russian literature is like American literature.



    13. Desde que le un art culo en Facebook sobre George Steiner me gustan sus opiniones sobre la literatura, el lenguaje y nuestro presente He le do a Tolstoi y Dostoievski m s por recomendaci n de otros, pero con este libro he comprendido la grandeza de estos escritores El libro alej ndose desde la cr tica estructural, ya que George dice, y en esto estoy completamente de acuerdo, que deber a existir una cr tica del amor hacia los cl sicos, m s all de desentra ar significados ocultos que hacen que un [...]


    14. If the first line is any indication, this will be a fantastic read Literary criticism should arise out of a debt of love Problem I haven t read any Tolstoy.Finished A magnificent book clear, eloquent, persuasive, powerfully synthetic, drawing on an extraordinary range of primary and secondary materials, in three or four languages And with all these virtues, Steiner manages to sound genuinely humble He was my age when he wrote it.


    15. An excellent study of the great Russian masters It is really accessible and contains interesting background information on the development of the European novel It is perfect as a primer for anyone looking to delve into the works of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky It is also great reading for those already familiar with both writers.


    16. If this is Old Criticism, than I say we bring Old Criticism back Reminds me a little of James Elkins in the personal, emotionally engaged criticism and relationship to a work That s what it s all about in the end right


    17. Excelente ensayo a vuelo de p jaro que contrasta dos fuerzas art sticas opuestas Aunque uno tienda a inclinarse a un extremo, el opuesto siempre acecha y cuestiona.






    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *