Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools

Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools By Diane Ravitch, Reign of Error The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America s Public Schools From one of the foremost authorities on education in the United States former U S assistant secretary of education whistle blower extraordinaire The Wall Street Journal author of the best selling
  • Title: Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools
  • Author: Diane Ravitch
  • ISBN: 9780385350884
  • Page: 235
  • Format: Hardcover
  • Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools By Diane Ravitch, From one of the foremost authorities on education in the United States, former U.S assistant secretary of education, whistle blower extraordinaire The Wall Street Journal , author of the best selling The Death and Life of the Great American School System Important and riveting Library Journal , The Language Police Impassioned Fiercely argued Every bFrom one of the foremost authorities on education in the United States, former U.S assistant secretary of education, whistle blower extraordinaire The Wall Street Journal , author of the best selling The Death and Life of the Great American School System Important and riveting Library Journal , The Language Police Impassioned Fiercely argued Every bit as alarming as it is illuminating The New York Times , andother notable books on education history and policy an incisive, comprehensive look at today s American school system that argues against those who claimitis broken and beyond repair an impassioned but reasoned call to stop the privatization movement that is draining students and funding from our public schools In Reign of Error, Diane Ravitch argues that the crisis in American education is not a crisis of academic achievement but a concerted effort to destroypublic schoolsin this country She makes clear that, contrary to the claims being made, public school test scores and graduation rates are the highest they ve everbeen, anddropout rates areat their lowest point Shearguesthatfederal programs such as George W Bush s No Child Left BehindandBarack Obama sRace to the Topsetunreasonable targets for American students, punish schools, andresult inteachersbeing firedif their students underperform, unfairly brandingthose educators as failures She warns that major foundations, individual billionaires, and Wall Street hedge fund managers are encouraging the privatization of public education, some for idealistic reasons, others for profit Many who work with equity funds are eyeing public education as an emerging market for investors Reign of Error begins where The Death and Life of the Great American School System leftoff, providing a deeper argument against privatization and for public education, andin a chapter by chapter breakdown, putting forth a plan for what can be done to preserveand improve it She makesclear what is right about U.Scation, how policy makers are failing to address the root causes of educational failure, andhow we can fix it For Ravitch, public school education is about knowledge, aboutlearning, about developingcharacter, and about creating citizens for our society It s abouthelping to inspireindependent thinkers, not just honing job skills or preparing people for college Public school educationis essential to our democracy, andits aim, since the founding of this country, has been toeducatecitizens who will help carry democracy into the future.
    Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools By Diane Ravitch,
    • [MOBI] ☆ Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools | by ☆ Diane Ravitch
      235 Diane Ravitch
    • thumbnail Title: [MOBI] ☆ Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools | by ☆ Diane Ravitch
      Posted by:Diane Ravitch
      Published :2020-01-26T17:10:24+00:00

    About "Diane Ravitch"

    1. Diane Ravitch

      Diane Ravitch Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools book, this is one of the most wanted Diane Ravitch author readers around the world.

    357 thoughts on “Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools”

    1. No other advanced society has threatened the public part of their public schools like has happened in the US Under the business ethos of anything the public sector can do the private one can do better , we ve gone remarkably far in privatizing one of our hallowed public goods, high quality K 12 education for all, and are now no where near the top in either academic achievement nor equality of access based on class, race, or national origin language differences.K 16 schooling is a source of big p [...]


    2. This isn t a great book in the usual sense of the word, but I m giving it five stars because I think there are few books out there that so intelligently and directly address this important issue at such a critical moment It often feels like the components of American public life are being sold, one after the other, to private parties that flash a vulpine smile and offer those perennially comforting words We ll take care of this for you Ravitch makes no mistake about assuring us that, as far as p [...]


    3. I can t remember the last time I was so frustrated reading a book I don t like to say a book is one star very often, because I believe one star represents some sort of irredeemable qualities that cannot be rescued Sadly, this is one of those books, as it s a pile of strawmen in a heap, knocked over by ridiculous conclusions and poor logic.On the basic stuff, I actually found myself nodding in agreement with her There are a lot of myths about education reform that should probably be addressed, th [...]


    4. This is the best defense of public schools I ve come across Americans who have not read this book are probably insufficiently informed to vote wisely in local and state elections.Contrary to what one might conclude from media reports, levels of educational achievement and graduation rates in the United States have been consistently rising over the years Surprise Achievement scores are now at their highest point ever recorded Achievement has been going up for all racial groups, but the gaps betwe [...]



    5. I understand why Ravitch is considered a saint by many progressives Education issues inevitably become heated, and Ravitch is a fierce adversary She arms herself with both both passionate argument and careful statistics but she never manages to wade too deep into either With each chapter clocking in at less than ten pages, she does a quick hit on why education reform types are corporate shills and then moves on, often using straw man arguments and contradictory evidence She defended the democrac [...]


    6. This is a superb book that critiques the current reform movement in American primary and secondary education Everybody who is interested in the state of public education should read Diane Ravitch s book carefully.Ravitch is an accomplished historian of American education who worked in the Department of Education during the reform efforts of President Bush She soured on the reform movement, rethought her positions, and has come to be sharply critical of this reform effort which is now quite mains [...]


    7. Students of current American public policy should have this book in their library Ravitch lays out a clear, compelling case that citizens and policy makers should act decisively to protect and save our nation s pubic education systems from short sighted profiteers and ideologues who understand neither the history or value of the fundamental institution that makes our nation great.Ravitch makes empirical, pragmatic and evidence based policy arguments in accessible prose to explain why public educ [...]


    8. Excellent Diane Ravitch not only presents the evidence against the reform movements, but provides solutions to the problems that are plaguing schools As a teacher at an apartheid school I agree with almost all of her arguments Teaching to the test and the focus on standardized tests is not what makes for a quality education Affluent and suburban schools would not stand for it, so why do our neediest children have to have schools this way I am glad that my district has managed to keep charters ou [...]


    9. This is not a balanced book full of facts and information to understand a complex problem if you are a learner and want to understand a system, don t read this book If you are already a Ravitch supporter and just want to read something to confirm your views rather than to think critically about how to solve problems, you will enjoy this book very much It is a narrow, one sided view that makes leaping conclusions that you would expect from someone who is looking for data to support her pre existi [...]


    10. 10 stars Please read this friends Even if you aren t usually interested in educational nitty gritty, read the book because this is affecting your kids schools I ve finally finished the last bit The last three chapters are important and sum up the problems with education and society, and the wrongness of the proposed reform solutions.I LOVE this I didn t wait to lend my book because this information has to become part of neighborhood wisdom in order to stop the steamroller of crap PR telling Amer [...]


    11. Diane Ravitch has validated my life in the classroom and what I have been saying for the past ten or years This is a must read for anyone concerned with education at any level She debunks some of the myths being bandied about, clarifies who is funding some of the so called reforms, and than provides some very clear thoughts on what really needs to be done to improve our educational system While there were times in past years that she and I were at odds about education, we are now on the same pa [...]


    12. Diane Ravitch has written the definitive account of the false promises behind the reform privatization movement in public education There is no better explanation of what is wrong with the push for charter school and standardized tests than within the pages of this book Ravitch doesn t stop with her well researched take down of the privatization movement She offers sound advice for fixing our broken schools, too This book should be read by every legislator in every state, every member of the U [...]


    13. I remember vividly a moment from my first year of teaching All teachers, K 12, were sitting in one room for a professional development day The superintendent was talking about some new initiative like many new initiatives it came and went, and I honestly do not recall what it was The veteran teacher sitting next to me, a woman I greatly admire and consider one of the best teachers I have ever had the pleasure to know and work with, whispered to me, this is not what it seems This is leading to th [...]


    14. Diane Ravitch is the rarest and finest of intellectuals one who both admits when they are wrong and then demonstrates the reasons why.Ravitch is a former Bush I Administration education official, and she targets her strongest criticism at the big guys, Bush II and Obama, whose reforms played into the hands of the charter and privatization crowds by dramatically increasing testing, and ratcheting up teacher evaluation and de unionization to inspire a mass exodus from a profession that was already [...]


    15. Fortunately, Ravitch is thorough in her call to arms against the move by a handful of leaders, entrepreneurs and politicians who want to turn public schools into private enterprises.Unfortunately, the book is quite repetitive as she uses the same ideas in multiple chapters.Fortunately, Ravitch cites research and specific cases to support her points Unfortunately, many are extremes, especially in her critique of charter schools I picture opponents using counter examples quite easily to support th [...]


    16. If you are at all interested in education, social issues, or politics, this book is a must read The facts presented here are solid, clear, and irrefutable public education is NOT on the decline in our country and any suggestion otherwise is the product of a massively powerful, insidious propaganda machine looking to privatize education for maximum profit and take the focus off the lack of basic services available for impoverished populations The real issue in our education system is the horrific [...]


    17. This is an important book For anyone even mildly interested in education policy, this is a must read It has been a long accepted fact that education in America is failing, and that things are getting worse, and that teacher unions are pretty much to fault for that, and that we need LOTS of tests to hold teachers and principals accountable Well, if you want a counter argument to that narrative, THIS BOOK IS IT If Ravitch is even half right, and I suspect her average is better than half, then we r [...]


    18. This is s tricky one to review I agree with a lot of Ravitch s conclusions, most especially that poverty has a huge effect on educational outcomes, and that our schools should take cues from the Finns Finland spent a generation raising the teaching profession to the same standards and compensation as doctors It worked She also sounds a much needed alarm about how corporate interests are using charter schools to feather their own nests.However, Ravitch also throws the baby out with the bathwater [...]


    19. An excellent book which lays out the dangers to public education, which is NOT failing, no matter what rich investors want people to believe Ravitch s research is overwhelming And spot on As a side note, I m always bothered when people suggest that teachers are failing our kids No Society is failing our kids I ve chosen a career that doesn t pay me much, and I knew that going in, so I m cool with that But to hear people suggest that I m not trying every day to make these kids better That I might [...]


    20. Ravitch was the assistant Secretary of Education under the first Bush In this book she presents a good case for what is wrong in education isn t the fault of teachers and bad teaching, but a concerted effort by certain interest groups to do away with public education in this country As a teacher who has watched to public schools be beaten up and attacked for nearly 20 years, I enjoyed what she had to say and agree with much of her theories I don t know is our schools can be saved as the movement [...]


    21. No surprises here if you ve ever been a public school teacher, especially in an urban area with poverty Everything has changed from when I began to teach in 1965 to when my subject was cut a few years ago I taught in 13 schools preschool, middle school, jr high, sr high, adult ed in 2 countries and 3 states The problems have not changed and solutions have not been addressed because it requires profound social change Poverty must be addressed Childhood poverty in the United States is higher than [...]


    22. An excellent book a friend calls it a handbook for activists and I agree Packed with information, evidence and a template for reclaiming public education THE education book of 2013.I don t usually do this, but here s my on line review blogs.edweek teachers teac


    23. A necessary read for anyone with a stake in public education, ahem everyone Ravitch debunks myth after myth that is spouted daily about the so called disastrous state of public education in America It s an eye opening call to action for all citizens in our democracy who wish for the U.S to remain democratic.


    24. The author, Diane Ravitch was the assistant secretary of education in the George HW Bush administration and also served under Clinton At that time she was a strong supporter of standards, testing, and accountability in education However, she now is strongly opposed to those principles as they are implemented through No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top She spends much of the book outlining the problems with these programs and the corporate reform movement that grew out of them.Her main point [...]


    25. Where do I begin I think I must start with Ravitch s previous book, DEATH AND LIFE OF THE GREAT AMERICAN SCHOOL SYSTEM I knew a bit about Ravitch, and her previous support for NCLB, and I was eager to see what had changed her mind I remember reading the book, quite literally talking back to the pages We TOLD you so We KNEW this wouldn t work When the law first passed, I stood toe to toe with a friend who tried to convince me that this was going to be a good thing I was unmoved I was right.So, to [...]


    26. Ok I was torn between three and four stars I didn t want to do three because I highly recommend this book despite its flaw, but the flaw is pretty much par for the course with the type of book that it is.I am a huge proponent of the opt out of standardized tests movement I have taught high school and been successful I know what it is required to get the worst students to do something I have opted my own children out of PA s Keystone Exams because they had my son ready to quit school despite dece [...]


    27. I gave this four stars only because it had a lot of repetition in it, the content is excellent.Ravitch has always been a supporter of public education, but here she shows how much of the educational reform movement is a sham, led by phony statistics by people with goals other than improving schools She argues that by all measures, schools are education and graduating kids than at any time in history I didn t realize that graduation statistics in the US only include kids who graduate in 4 years [...]


    28. If you have read Ravitch before, you have read this book She rehashes the arguments routinely employed by critics of the billionaire reformers work and charter schools, which, in their view, constitute not choice but privatization, evidence of the consumer model of education Much as we would delight in the notion of the public good, the hyper consumerism of our late capitalism has commodified everything We can lament it and decry it, but it is largely so, just ask librarians who have seen their [...]


    29. While large parts of Ravitch s claims are evidence based and supported by ample research, her frequent use of straw man arguments and anecdotal evidence makes it hard to trust her presentation of the remainder of her arguments I approached this book hoping to learn about the complicated issue of education both public and private in America today It was so biased as to be unhelpful in that regard Ravitch s goal is not to inform, but to persuade specifically to persuade her reader that public sch [...]


    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *